Performance of astrologers
To date, I am aware of only three
published studies that were carried out
in double-blind
conditions – a prerequisite for good quality data accepted by the
scientific community.
Double-blind = neither the
test subjects nor the researchers knew which document(s) corresponded to each
subject. The documents were anonymized
by a third party and bore a code that enabled their subsequent identification
for interpretation purposes.
The three studies are:
Carlson S Nature vol 318; Dec 5, 1985 – No 1
Carlson S Nature vol 318; Dec 5, 1985 – No 2
McGrew&McFall J Scient Exploration vol 4 no 1 -1990
Of note, several
blinded studies on the performance of astrologers were carried out earlier and
never published. The first ones by the
psychologist Vernon Clark were successful, but subsequent studies provided
conflicting results. A review of these
trials, together with a meta-analysis pooling results, was carried out by Geoffrey
Dean, one of the authors contributing to Astrology and Science